What does Elixir add on top of Erlang?
Erlang provides excellent concurrency, scalability and fault tolerance. Elixir starts with this mature platform and adds:
- Powerful language features like macros
- Protocols for polymorphism
- An object oriented syntax, but without tight coupling
This makes Elixir highly productive while retaining Erlang’s benefits:
From Erlang:
- Concurrency
- Scalability
- Fault tolerance
Elixir adds:
- Macros
- Protocols
- OO syntax without coupling
Why is Phoenix more maintainable than Rails at scale?
Rails makes it very easy to build simple apps, but can cause issues as projects grow:
- Business logic gets embedded in models and controllers
- High coupling between components
- “Magic” features become problematic
Phoenix improves on Rails by:
- Separating business logic from web layers
- Reducing coupling via functional approach
- Less “magic” conventions
So Phoenix improves scalability by reducing entanglement in large projects.
What are the benefits of LiveView for simpler UIs?
LiveView shines for apps that previously used jQuery for simple dynamic UIs:
- Allows reactive UIs with less JavaScript
- No need for complex frameworks like React
- Templates and state live in backend
- Fast development, less code
So it’s ideal for apps with lightweight interactivity needs.
When is client-side JavaScript better than LiveView?
LiveView has limitations:
- No offline support
- Complex UIs still better in JavaScript
- Latency constraints
So for complex UIs like Google Sheets, or offline apps, a JavaScript framework is better.
How does Elixir handle concurrency?
Elixir uses the BEAM VM concurrency model:
- Lightweight processes for concurrent work
- Share nothing - processes communicate via messages
- Processes are isolated - no shared state
This makes it easy to handle millions of concurrent connections.
How does Phoenix provide real-time features?
Phoenix has first-class support for WebSockets via Channels:
- Abstraction for persistent connections
- Presence tracking for online users
- PubSub for event broadcasting
Channels make it easy to build real-time systems like chat without added complexity.
What are the pros of Elixir over Node.js?
Compared to Node.js, Elixir has several advantages:
- Faster due to the BEAM VM
- More reliable - rarely crashes
- Lightweight processes scale better
- Immutability avoids huge class of bugs
- Everything included - no need for extra tools
So Elixir improves over Node.js in performance, reliability and productivity.
When is Go a better choice than Elixir?
Go shines for building very fast network services where efficiency matters more than productivity:
- CPU bound network services
- Calling into C libraries
- GC avoids memory bugs
- Built-in CSP concurrency
So for large infrastructure with extreme performance needs, Go may be a better choice.
References
ref:
- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20852872
- https://www.quora.com/Elixir-vs-node-js-vs-Go-which-one-wins-in-building-scalable-real-time-chat
- https://www.cogini.com/blog/advantages-of-elixir-vs-golang/
- https://pentacent.com/blog/failing-big-elixir-liveview/
- https://itnext.io/add-react-to-phoenix-92c590fbbc7f
- https://scorpil.com/post/things-elixirs-phoenix-framework-does-right/
- https://earthly.dev/blog/real-time-phoenix-elixir/
- https://www.monterail.com/blog/ruby-vs-elixir